When you buy something fake, it definitely goes beyond the amount of money you have spent/lost; you feel so cheated and deceived and I think that’s the feeling that comes through when you look at the fake item. I was very lucky that I got my money back from Ebay and I was able to purchase the authentic Lorac Pro Palette which I recently reviewed here. But let’s start at the beginning, shall we? Towards the end of 2014, I think around Oct/Nov 2014, I was on the haunt for the Lorac Pro Palette but I did not want to spend a fortune getting it from other retailers that shipped to the UK since it was virtually impossible to purchase this directly from Lorac. Of course, I went on Amazon UK and found out it cost £60 and I subsequently fled. Next stop was Ebay where I saw a plethora of Lorac Pro Palettes and I thought I could find a seller who may have gone to the States to purchase a few and needed some quick cash. Some of them were from US sellers who were selling it for almost £70 but there were a few UK sellers that sold it for normal prices. I decided to apply my Ebay Shopping Tips and search for a good seller. I finally found one who had 100% positive feedback and had sold several products including Lorac Pro Palettes and Benefit Cosmetics.
I made an offer, she made a counter offer and then we settled for a middle ground which seemed fair and I paid for it via PayPal (thank goodness for that!). I was glad my Ebay Shopping tips had helped me although I did not follow one tip which turned out to be my downfall. Yes, the one about my instinct. I had this silent nagging feeling that the said palette may not be authentic but I kept shutting it down until I decided to email the seller (after I had already paid). I wanted to find out if she bought it in the States and a few other questions. No answer and this was shocking as she was very good at communicating shortly before payment. At this point, I already had the sinking gut feeling you get when you realise you have been royally screwed and I just waited the product to be delivered. My instincts were right; it was fake. To be fair, it was very difficult to tell because it looked very similar to the original palette at least from the pictures I had seen. Of course, I opened up a dispute case and I got a full refund back even though the seller was so fraudulent that she never left her complete address. I never got to return the disgusting palette because there was no address to return it to which is why I still have it for this post. I hope these tips will help you spot a fake Lorac Pro Palette...
Eyeshadow Pans
The eyeshadow in the pans of the original palette are well placed and fitted in the palette and you can see that utmost care was taken in manufacturing it while the fake one has the eyeshadows placed unevenly and it just looks really dodgy. Surprisingly, there are no spelling errors in the names of the eyeshadows of the fake palette. The corners of the eyeshadow pans of the original palette are slightly rounded while the fake one has a proper sharp square corner.
Behind the Scenes Eyeshadow Primer
Both primers look very similar and again, it's hard to tell the difference but on closer examination, you can see slight differences. First off, the fake palette's primer is slightly longer than the original one and it just looks a little bit bigger. The fonts in the fake palette are also larger and they don't look as sharp as the original one. The textures of both primers are also different; the original one has more texture to it and comes out without breaking while the fake one is less textured and feels slightly watery. Lastly, there is a spelling error at the back of the fake primer and it reads "indmduelle" instead of "individuelle"...*smh*
Pigmentation of the Eyeshadows
The most glaring difference in both palettes is the pigmentation of the eyeshadows. The matte lighter shades in the fake palette hardly showed up when swatched while the same shades had such incredible pigmentation in the original palette. Seriously, my mouth popped open when I did a comparison. To be fair to the fake palette, the darker shimmer shades looked okay but they looked much different to how the same shades looked in the original palette. It's really shocking to see how poor the pigmentation of the fake palette is.
Overall Thoughts
Ladies (and guys), never use fake eyeshadows (or any products) on your eyes (or face) because they may contain very harmful ingredients. As mentioned, I was very lucky to get my money back because I paid with PayPal and Ebay helped me sort everything out although it took a little while. Sometimes, it is very hard to distinguish the fake palette from the real one but you can always email Lorac Cosmetics with the batch number/code and ask them if they ever made that particular batch. I would not advise anyone to buy this palette from Ebay as there are so many fake ones out there. Save your pennies if you are really desperate and buy from a good source or maybe ask someone in the States to help you. I hope this post and pictures have been helpful to you. See you in my next post...xx
oh wow indeed the packaging looks really similar but the quality of the shadows is incredibly different!!! I ordered mine from amazon.com and payed the shipping costs but with the exchange from dollars being good, it cost me only 56 euros, which is what a naked palette costs approximately. I got the pro, pro 2 and mega pro and was always very happy
ReplyDeletexo
Alice|Alice's Beauty Madnesse
Thanks for your comment and I am so pleased that you purchased an authentic one (or ones). The people making fake items are getting worse by the day as it's so hard to tell the difference but the spelling errors and pigmentation are an immediate sign!!....xx
DeleteThis post is amazing! After reading this, I am so weary now of buying from places that arent the 'actual' site for the brand I am buying.
ReplyDeleteVery detailed review and amazing photos! So happy you got a refund but at least you were able to make such an informative post from the experience xx
lauren | shynature.blogspot.co.uk
Awww thank you so much for that! I am glad you enjoyed this post and I hope this post (and my experience) will prevent people form making the same mistake as I did!!...xx
DeleteThis is really helpful and shows it doesn't have to be a high-end product for fakes to be floating around! I would only ever buy direct from Amazon! xx
ReplyDeleteMagpie Jasmine || Palette Giveaway: Urban Decay, Nars, Charlotte Tilbury, Too Faced
Thank you so much!! and Yes to buying from Amazon..I guess fake manufacturers realised how much of a best seller the Lorac Pro Palette was and decided to cash in....xx
Deleteomg! omg! omg!
ReplyDeleteI wouldnt have thought in a million years that a counterfeit will look so close!! and a counterfeit of LORAC! *faints*
My dear, the things fraudsters will do for some minute cash is unbelievable. They have market intelligence to understand that the Lorac Pro Palette is well loved hence they decided to make fake ones which look really similar to the real deal and I am sure many people have fallen prey to them!!...xx
DeleteThank you for your post! My fake palette was the same as yours and it was hard to tell because it was so close to the original. Most other fake vs real comparisons use a palette that is far from the real thing so I was still in doubt after seeing their comparisons. Your post showed me that mine was indeed fake!
ReplyDeleteI am so pleased you enjoyed this post but it's so sad that your palette was the fake one. If you bought it from Ebay, you can get your money back (if it's within the specified time). It's very heartbreaking buying something fake; you just feel absolutely cheated and annoyed when you look at the said product. These fake ass manufacturers are so good with making fake products that it's pretty hard to detect. Thanks for stopping by...xx
DeleteI brought my palette from Instagram. Many cust give feedback that she sell original makeup. When I get my palette the color especially taupe really really not pigmented and the primer smell so plastic! My god I save money for long to buy the original one.
ReplyDeleteOh dear!! That's so awful and very annoying that people could sell fake items on Ebay and Instagram. I am actually surprised they could do that on Instagram. It's awful!! I am so sorry to hear that you have experienced this and I hope someday you can get the real palette. Any time I look at the fake palette; I feel so annoyed so I can understand how you feel. Thanks for stopping by and commenting and also sharing your story....xx
DeleteThank you for this post. I am have been buying my palettes from the States especially from Anasthesia Beverley Hills. I was getting fed up of having to pay customs fees in addition to the shipping costs which makes the palette 2 and a half times the cost for me. I was thinking of waiting for people who sell on EBay but having read your post I definitely won't do that. Thank you do much for sharing this.
ReplyDeleteI am so pleased you found this post useful and at least it would help prevent you from fake sellers. I totally get what you mean and I am the same!! There are so many amazing products I want to get my hands on but they are always available in the US which is such a pain especially when we are slammed a huge custom fee!! I wouldn't advise anyone to buy from Ebay. It's best to give a relative to help in the US if you have one, buy directly from Amazon (not their sellers but Amazon themselves) or try Cult Beauty who stock Anastasia Beverly Hills...xx
DeleteWowzers... this is really helpful! The fakes always look so real as well :'( This happened to me recently with some fake RT Bold Metals brushes but I wasn't able to get my money back :(( I've definitely been put off buying anything from Ebay! xxx
ReplyDeleteChristine | www.yveschild.com
Honestly, it's so hard to tell fakes these days and I keep wondering why people even go through the lengths of making such a "good" fake when they can channel that energy and create an amazing indigenous makeup product!! I am so sorry you could not get your money back!! Did you use PayPal and dispute with Ebay. Mine took a little while but I was very determined in getting my money back. I am so weary of Ebay for high end products as well!!...xx
Delete:-( i went through Ebay but the seller had deleted their account by the time the Ebay got round to resolving the case... Ebay claimed there was nothing they could do about it.. such is life! lol i've learnt my lesson xx
Deleteomgggg!!!! mine was fake all along!!!! hahaha this is funny thanks for the info! :D now i gotta go buy the real one!
ReplyDeleteOhhh Noo!! So sorry to hear that!! Some of these fake sellers are so good that you can hardly tell!! Hope you are able to get the real deal soon...xx
DeleteI bought a fake lorac mega pro 3 palette on eBay and I'm so disappointed definitely don't buy any beauty products on eBay! Pay the $59
ReplyDeleteOhhh no!! That sounds so awful. I always try and steer clear of makeup from Ebay especially if the prices seem too good to be true!! Hope you got your money back at least!!..xx
DeleteI love your photography
ReplyDelete